james and the giant peach

review by rob gonsalves

director
Henry Selick

screenwriters
Karey Kirkpatrick
Jonathan Roberts
Steve Bloom
based on the novel by
Roald Dahl

producers
Tim Burton
Denise Di Novi

cinematographers
Pete Kozachik
Hiro Narita

music
Randy Newman

editor
Stan Webb


cast

Paul Terry (James)
Simon Callow
(Grasshopper)
Richard Dreyfuss
(Centipede)
Jane Leeves
(Ladybug)
Joanna Lumley
(Aunt Spiker)
Miriam Margolyes
(Aunt Sponge)
Pete Postlethwaite
(Old Man)
Susan Sarandon
(Spider)
David Thewlis
(Earthworm)


mpaa rating: PG
running time: 79m
u.s. release: 4/12/96
video availability: VHS - DVD


other henry selick films
reviewed on this website:

- monkeybone
- the nightmare before christmas


Did anyone else out there see Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory as a kid and never get over it? That movie and 1990's equally disturbing (but fun) The Witches came from the twisted brow of Roald Dahl, who didn't worry about scaring kids any more than he worried about offending parents. Dahl's books for kids are cold and vengeful, yet restlessly inventive. If 1995 was Jane Austen's year, 1996 looks to be Dahl's. This summer promises Danny DeVito's adaptation of Matilda, and this month offers James and the Giant Peach, from the same creative team behind The Nightmare Before Christmas -- director Henry Selick, producer Tim Burton -- plus character design by children's book illustrator Lane Smith (The Stinky Cheese Man). Why such a potential blockbuster has been dumped in the post-Easter death slot is beyond me. (Unlike Christ, movies that die on opening weekend don't rise again in three days.) Peach, like Nightmare, should please all ages: jaded kids as well as jaded adults who grew up on Rankin-Bass stop-motion TV specials. This is Disney's true art nowadays, not PC crap like Pocahontas.

In the live-action prologue, little James (Paul Terry) loses both his parents to a rhino and moves in with his horrid aunts Sponge (Miriam Margolyes) and Spiker (Joanna Lumley). Life sucks until James meets a mysterious old-timer (Pete Postlethwaite), who gives the boy a bag of magic alligator tongues. But the tongues slip from James' hands, burrowing into the dirt around a tree bearing a single peach. As advertised, the peach inflates to asteroidal proportions. Once James enters the peach (a naughty Dahl-esque joke that has gone over kids' heads since the book's 1961 publication), the movie shifts to Selick's witty animation and Lane Smith's surreal critters. Among the latter are Old-Green-Grasshopper (voice of Simon Callow), Ladybug (Jane Leeves of Frasier), Miss Spider (Susan Sarandon), Centipede (Richard Dreyfuss), and the neurotic, blind Earthworm (David Thewlis), who's much funnier than he was in the book.

Selick and the screenwriters (Karey Kirkpatrick, Jonathan Roberts, and Steve Bloom) beef up some of Dahl's inventions and disregard others. In the book, a pack of sharks menace the ocean-bound peach. In the movie, Selick and Smith bring out a fearsome RoboShark, complete with flying shark-missiles. I did, however, mourn the absence of Dahl's Cloud Men, and Disney chickens out on the fates of Sponge and Spiker. Selick spares them; Dahl cackled as he let the peach squash them flat.

James and the Giant Peach poops out at the end, when the movie returns to live action; the aunts show up, and James makes a lame speech about the importance of dreams. But most of the movie, loyal to the spirit (if not always to the text) of Roald Dahl, has already made the point. Henry Selick's images are both lyrical and tactile: You can almost touch and taste that peach as it floats around, and strange and beautiful things are happening inside it.



home - q&a - miscellany - cool links - rare video resources
cult movies archive - tirades - contact